• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Al
  • Playing Guitar at Home
  • Guitar care at home
  • Gear and Accessories
  • Contact Al

Hobby Guitarist

Devoted to maximizing fulfilment for hobby guitarists with limited free time

All Posts

What is the Best Guitar Pick

December 15, 2016 by Al F 6 Comments

To answer the question “What is the best guitar pick?”, I have compiled the guitar pick guide as, like so many aspects of guitar playing, the guitar pick (or plectrum) has a bewildering array of varieties and a massive amount of un-necessary mystique in my opinion.

It is the second factor in the chain that creates the sound however, so does contribute considerably to the overall sound coming out of the speaker and is worth some real experimentation for each individual.

Read below and formulate an idea of what sort of pick might suit you, then source a few different types to try. They are not that expensive and it’s well worth buying a good variety and trying them out.

Let’s first consider what the basic differentiators are in a pick:

  • Size – the physical dimensions when viewed flat;
  • Thickness – pretty much equates to the stiffness of the pick;
  • Shape – the outline shape together with points and/or curves;
  • Texture – whether the surface is smooth or matt and whether it has some sort of grip moulded in;
  • Material – typically, celluloid, nylon and other plastic derivatives, more exotic substances like delrin, ultem and tortex; some even use bone, wood, metal, stone or leather!
Picture of Lots of Guitar Picks around an acoustic guitar sound hole
Lots of Guitar Picks

So why so much variety? I could be cynical and suggest that manufacturers have a vested interest in claiming new properties for given styles of pick and new exotic materials, but there are some basic things to consider.

If you want to cut to the chase, you can’t go far wrong choosing Jim Dunlop guitar picks or Ernie Ball guitar picks. Some players also like Fender guitar picks especially those that try to capture the vintage feel.
For electric guitar picks go for the thicker picks (0.85mm or above).
For acoustic guitar picks go for 0.85mm or less but more typically, 0.65mm or under.

My personal preference as an electric guitar player is for the John Petrucci Jazz III Dunlop picks – They have a nice grip, glide over the strings and last a long time (plus they sound great – especially in John’s rather capable hands!)

Let’s look in a little more detail at the various properties above but do bare in mind that many of the properties below combine in different ways and also depend on the way in which you use the pick and it’s contact with the string(s).

Size

  • The physical dimensions – largely falls into 3 categories, but this is a huge generalisation :
    • Small – approximately 7/8”(22.2mm) +-1/16”(1.5mm) inch long, these got popular in the 90’s when the “stubby” was first introduced;
    • Medium approximately 1-1/8”(28.5mm) +- 1/16”(1.5mm) – this is a very typical size of pick, and the majority of picks are of this size;
    • Large approximately 1-1/4”(31.7mm) and larger- covers a huge range as there are some truly massive picks out there.
  • These appear to be small differences in size, but when you are holding a pick, these small differences in size actually become more apparent.

Thickness

  • This is probably the most important aspect of a pick;
  • Thicknesses fall into 4 main categories (thickness is nearly always quoted in mm (millimetres)):
    • Thin – under 0.6mm (including X-thin 0.45mm and under);
    • Medium – 0.60mm to 0.85mm;
    • Thick 0.85mm to 1.2mm;
    • X-thick – 1.2mm and up (can go to 3mm!).
  • Strumming equals X-thin and thin (mainly acoustic, gives the characteristic acoustic sound);
  • Strumming with single note lines equals medium to give flex for strumming as well as enough rigidity for single note clarity;
  • Thick and X-thick equals what most electric players will use to increase accuracy and articulation;
  • The thicker picks produce a more “solid” sound whereas the thinner picks give, err, a thinner sound.
Picture of A Green Guitar Pick
A Green Guitar Pick

Shape

  • Picks vary in overall shape from the typical “rounded triangle” shape to perfectly triangular (so it doesn’t matter which way you hold it). There are also variations on the “roundedness” of the tip, some being really quite pointed, others more “curvy”:
  • There are some picks with actual notches or cerations for string scratching etc.


Texture

  • This is mainly about whether the pick has been “roughed up” giving it a matt texture;
  • About whether the pick has moulded grip under your fingers to avoid it slipping (particularly useful when the temperature/intensity goes up!).

Material

  • Might affect the tone – the harder the substance, the more sharpness and attack you are likely to get (try using a coin and then a thin piece of wood to hear the extremes of this);
  • Might affect flexibility and springiness of the pick for a given thickness;
  • Might affect durability – although this is not so much of a factor these days;
  • Might dictate that the pick feels smooth/shiny or more porous – this may subtly affect the tone but also the feeling when holding the pick.


In Conclusion

Narrow down thickness first, based on your playing style and the sound you want, then try different materials and shapes to find what’s comfortable for you and don’t be afraid to experiment – this is one of the cheapest items you need as a hobby guitarist so you can probably afford to try a few different types.

I highly recommend Dunlop guitar picks and Ernie Ball guitar picks.

I hope you found some useful information here – please do remember that articles are aimed at the full spectrum of hobby guitarists, so you may find that you already know some things but not others.

Check back regularly for new content and use the posting categories drop down for other relevant posts.

Please do comment below on my answer to “what is the best guitar pick”, I really value your opinion.

All the best and keep on rockin’

Al

Filed Under: Guitar Picks Tagged With: guitar pick, picks, plectrums

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Marty says

    February 2, 2017 at 5:24 pm

    Hey Al,
    Great article on pics,very informative. I don’t use them because I have a problem holding on to them so I use my fingers and sometimes a thumb pick.
    A friend of mine would go to antique stores and buy old torte shell combs for women’s hair. He would make picks from them. They have a property that has a low click sound. The problem is that it is illegal to harvest torte shell and you have to prove that it was from prior to the ban.
    Could you recommend a pick that would be easy to hand on to. My style goes from chording to individual notes so a medium would probably be best.
    Marty

    Reply
    • Al F says

      February 3, 2017 at 6:10 pm

      Hi Marty and thanks for your comment.

      If you want something to try and have an issue with grip, I’d suggest trying the Dunlop Max-Grip nylon standard picks (#449).

      These have a nice texture to grip and are otherwise standard picks.

      I would suggest that you try their 3 thinnest picks .60mm, .73mm or .88mm – if you only wanted one, then go for the .73mm.

      Picks are really quite cheap compared to even strrings, so it’s definitely worth buying a good selection to try, but these picks are good work horses.

      Hope that helps, and have fun playing!

      Al

  2. Lauren says

    January 17, 2017 at 11:02 pm

    The guitar pick I have is on the thinner side and sometimes when I’m playing it slips out from between my fingers and inside my guitar – which is really annoying when you have to shake it to try to get it out. Are there certain picks that are easier to hold? Also, I had no idea that there were picks specifically for string scratching, I’ll definitely have to try that.

    Reply
    • Al F says

      January 18, 2017 at 11:53 pm

      Hi Lauren,

      OMG – the “my pick fell in to my guitar” thing used to happen to me all the time as well! Why do those things bounce around in there and refuse to come out?

      Most likely, this is because you are not holding the pick hard enough. The temptation is to hold the pick more lightly to carresse the sound.

      You want to control the pick so that you get the chords/notes you want, so you need to really hang on to that pick and control where it goes, how hard and at what time.

      Perhaps try a thinner pick for a while so you feel more confident addressing the strings, but make sure you hang on to it – you are wanting to control the rhythm and the notes, so make sure that pick does what you want!

      Also, find some picks with a grip on them – a lot of the Ernie Ball picks for example have a dotted texture where you hold them and that might help a lot.

      Just remember, the things you are playing are controlled by that pick and how it contacts the strings, so keep control of it; hold on to it and let the flex of the pick do the hard work.

      Please write back if you want any more advice – we are all hobby guitarists here!

      All the best,

      Al

  3. Craig says

    January 3, 2017 at 10:51 pm

    When I played guitar I preferred using thicker picks. I was playing acoustic guitar and I notice you recommend using thinner picks for acoustic – maybe this is why I was never any good!

    I have managed to collect a few picks from attending concerts in my youth. Most memorably Paul Weller and Noel Gallagher’s were in my collection.

    Reply
    • Al F says

      January 4, 2017 at 11:15 pm

      Picks from Paul Weller and Noel Gallagher? That’s very cool!

      Generally speaking, with an acoustic guitar you are mainly strumming so a thinner pick will “glide” better and give that characteristic sound. If you tend to throw in a few single note lines between chords, then medium is a good compremise.

      A thicker pick will tend to “bounce” a little more and be harder to control on the thicker strings of an acoustic and probably won’t sound so “fluid”.

      But then, it’s all a bout what you are comfortable with – trial and error – horses for courses; this is just a guide based on my experience.

      I hope this inspires you to pick up the guitar again!

      All the best,

      Al

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Primary Sidebar

Why Not Stay In Touch?

HG Tells...

Hi Al here - subscribe to the HG Tells newsletter - An occasional email with a synopsis of news and content from The Hobby Guitarist.


I believe in the "less is more" principle of communication; if I don't have much to say, I won't send you an email!

 

Success! Now check your email to confirm your subscription.

 

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

   
 
 
   

Recent Comments

  • Al F on Review – Ernie Ball M Steel Strings
  • marco on Review – Ernie Ball M Steel Strings
  • Al F on Guitarist in Focus #2 – Marc Bonilla
  • Mark Robertson on Guitarist in Focus #2 – Marc Bonilla
  • Al F on Review – Ernie Ball M Steel Strings

Footer

Affiliate Disclosure

Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 · Lifestyle Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in